Posts Tagged ‘Notice Requirements’

Pro-Owner ‘Trick’ in the Delaware and Pro-Contractor ‘Trick’ in the Louisiana Lien Statutes

Here and there, there are statutes within a state’s lien laws that allow a property owner to place a duty of performance on subcontractors and contractors.

When representing property owners, savvy construction attorneys will recommend that these statutes be utilized to protect the owner from future liens.

An example of these types of statutes can be found in Delaware, under the Code Title 25, Section 2705.  The statute provides simply as follows:

The owner of any structure built, repaired or altered by any contractor or subcontractor may require such contractor or subcontractor from time to time to furnish and submit to him a complete and accurate list in writing of all persons who have furnished labor or material, or both, in connection therewith, and who may be entitled to avail themselves of the provisions of this chapter. Should any such contractor or subcontractor fail to furnish such list for 10 days after demand made therefor by such owner, he shall be entitled to receive no further payments from the owner until such list be furnished and shall not be entitled to avail himself of any of the provisions of this chapter.

What does this mean?

Well, quite simply, if an owner makes this “demand” in writing, the contractor or subcontractor ought to immediately comply or risk losing the ability to file a lien.

Unlike Delaware, Louisiana has a reverse requirement…allowing the contractor or subcontractor to burden the property owner with future performance with the risk of penalty for non-compliance.

La. R.S. 9:4822(K) provides that any person with lien rights may give a certain notice to the property owner, and if provided properly, the owner will be required to notify that person within 3 days of the filing of a notice of termination, the substantial completion or the abandonment of the work.  Of course, these events trigger time requirements under the lien statute.

What happens when an owner fails to provide this notice?   They are liable for “all costs and attorney’s fees for the establishment and the enforcement of the claim.”

Posted in:     Mechanics Lien  /  Tags: , , ,   /   Leave a comment

7 Habits of Contractors Who Lose Money…and How to Break Them

The Construction Commando’s “Contractor’s Secret Weapon” published an article with this title that described seven instances when contractors lose money on a project.  While the article was drafted to an audience of California contractors, the habits apply nationwide.

It will be to any contractors’ benefit to review this article online, access which habits apply to you, and make an effort to avoid the costly mistakes.  Any progress will help increase your bottom line.

The seven habits highlighted are:

1)    The “Gentlemen’s Agreement” – A Handshake and Your Word.   Bottom line:  Get it in writing.
2)    Using Contracts that Fall Short of the Legal Requirements.
3)    Not Getting Every Change Order in Writing.
4)    Failing to invoice immediately.
5)    Failing to serve a preliminary 20-day notice (pre-lien construction notices)
6)    Don’t Worry – They Will “Take Care of You” on the Next Job
7)    It isn’t good “customer service” to record a Mechanic’s Lien

Posted in:     Uncategorized  /  Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,   /   Leave a comment

All Notices Are Not Created Equal: Prelim Notice v Notice of Intent to Lien

In the world of construction liens, the word “Notice” gets frequent use. The technical nature of each state’s notice requirements, however, are often misunderstood.

In general, there are 2 types of “notices” required by lien statutes: Preliminary Notice & Notice of Intent to Lien.

Preliminary Notice vs. Notice of Intent to Lien
A “Preliminary Notice” must usually be provided to the notified party before work begins on a construction project, or within a certain time frame from when materials and/or materials are first furnished.

A “Notice of Intent to Lien,” on the other hand, must usually be provided to the notified party before filing a lien, usually 7-15 days before the filing.

As you can see from these simple definitions, the requirements are extremely different. And it’s safe to assume that if your project and state requires notice, the failure to send it will result in the forfeiture of your company’s lien rights.

When Is Notice Required?
Every state’s requirements are different – and unfortunately, quite technical. Not only does the technical nature of lien statutes make them difficult to understand and interpret, but they also result in sometimes absurd consequences.

Here are some general notice trends:

  • Frequent Rule #1: Almost every state has notice requirements when work is being performed on an “owner-occupied” residence. In theory, this is to protect homeowners from getting burned and having to pay contractors twice. Some states (like Pennsylvania) even prohibit liens against single family homeowner residences. If you’re working on an “owner-occupied” residence – check your state’s lien laws.

  • Frequent Rule #2: The further down the chain you are, the more likely notice is required. Across the nation, there are more notice requirements for subcontractors than prime contractors, and more notice requirements for sub-subcontractors and suppliers than 1st tier subcontractors. If you’re contracting with a subcontractor – check your state’s lien laws.


ExpressLien.Com
has one of the best free resources for construction lien laws in the United States. View our FAQs, state lien law outlines and summaries, and even download free lien forms on our public wiki: http://wiki.expresslien.com.

If you’re looking for information about your state, you can go to the state directory at http://states.expresslien.com, or simply enter http://yourstate.expresslien.com in as a URL. Of course, in place of “your state,” you should enter your state’s name.

Notice Chart
Here is a quick-glance “notice chart” giving you shorthand rules about the notice requirements in the states we service. Click Here.

Posted in:     Uncategorized  /  Tags: , , ,   /   1 Comment

Is Notice Required Before Filing a Construction Lien? Washington Law

It’s difficult to stress how beneficial filing a lien can be for your company when attempting to collect on a non-paying project. However, this begs the very important, and sometimes difficult to answer question: Are you legally entitled to lien?

In virtually every state, including Washington, the lien statutes are drafted with a certain balance. On the one hand, the statutes were created to grant those involved with the construction of a project a privilege on the properties they build or improve. On the other hand, however, the statutes have mechanisms within to protect the property owners from being liened improperly, or otherwise without notice.

Unfortunately, the notice requirements are oftentimes confusing and technical. It is important, however, that your organization understand these requirements. If you lien a project without following these notice procedures, you will have filed an improper lien, and this could subject you to owing the property owner damages, penalties and/or attorneys fees.

The notice requirements in Washington are actually quite clear – the general rule is simply that everyone is required to provide notice to the owner (and/or contractor) except for those who are specifically excluded.

This post breaks the notice requirements into two categories. Category one is the catch-all, and regards all types of projects that do not fall into category two. Category two regards construction projects for the improvement of an existing owner-occupied residential property.

Category One – The “Catch All”
Category one projects are all of those projects that do not fit within category two. This, therefore, includes every commercial project, and virtually every new residential project.

Washington statutes provide that written notice of a right to claim a lien must be given to the owner or reputed owner in every circumstances except:

1) Persons or companies who contract directly with the owner or owner’s agent;

2) Laborers for any claim that is based solely on labor; and

3) Subcontractors who have contracted with the prime contractor

To properly deliver notice, the notice must be in writing and must be given to the owner either through certified or registered mail and/or personally delivered.

For the sake of clean record-keeping, it’s a good practice to send the notice via certified mail with return receipt requested, and to keep record of the certified mail number. If you send the notice via hand delivery, you will want to get signed acknowledgment of receipt to later prove that the notice was sent.

Category Two – Improvements to Existing Owner-Occupied Single Family Residence

Category two projects are very limited in scope. They include only improvements to existing owner-occupied single family residences.

The following are examples of Category Two projects:

  • Improvement of kitchen to existing structure on a single family residence that is owned by the person occupying the home;
  • Adding a new room or new addition to existing structure on a single family residence that is owned by the person occupying the home.

The following are examples of projects that are not Category two projects:

  • Improvement of kitchen to an existing structure on a single family residence that is occupied by a tenant, and not the owner of the property;
  • New construction of owner-occupied residence.

When a project can be classified as a “Category Two” project, notice is required from the following parties:

1) Persons who do not contract directly with the owner-occupier, or their agent.

Therefore, if you are a handyman and you contracted directly with the owner, you would have the right to file a lien without providing the owner with a notice of lien rights. However, if you are a subcontractor hired by a handyman to do electrical work in a category two project, you would be required to provide notice of lien rights.

Summary
The goal of the Washington statute’s notice requirements is to protect the owner from being liened by a contractor who is not authorized to perform work on the property and/or by a contractor with no direct link to the owner.

When a contractor is hired by the owner directly, there is no need for that contractor to notify them that work is being performed at their property; the owner should know this as a result of the contract.

When not hired directly by the owner, however, to satisfy the purposes of the statute the contractor is usually required to provide notice to the owner that work is being performed. There are a few exceptions, as above-noted.

What is Notice?

All of this talk about notice begs an important question: what is notice?

Washington statutes are very clear about what constitutes notice and what does not – the statutes even provide the public with a preferred form for notice.

The notice from the applicable Washington statutes have been converted to a PDF and properly formatted, and is made available to you on this blog post. You can:

Click Here for PDF of Washington Notice.

What Happens If I Don’t Provide Notice?
In Washington, notice is a prerequisite to filing a construction lien. Therefore, if you do not file notice, you will not be able to file a valid lien.

It is good practice to send notice of lien rights before work on a construction project begins. This will ensure that you lien rights are protected as to all work performed on the project. However, even if you have not delivered notice at the beginning of the project, you may still have the ability to lien the project to a certain degree.

Regarding Category one projects, a lien can be filed only as to the work, services, materials, etc. performed and/or delivered sixty (60) days before the notice is delivered.

For example, if you started work on January 1st, and delivered notice of lien on August 1st, you could only file a lien on the construction project for work performed in June, July, August and beyond. You would have lost the right to file a lien against the property for work performed between January 1st and June.

While this is the general rule for Category one projects (60 days before notice delivered), there is an exception. In the case of new construction of a single family residence, the lien can be filed only as to the work, services, materials, etc. performed and/or delivered ten (10) days before the notice is delivered. As you can see, this is a significant exception.

Regarding Category two projects, the lien may be satisfied only from amounts not yet paid to the prime contractor by the owner at the time the notice is received. Again, this is a significant exception.

Conclusion
The notice requirements in Washington are important, but also simple. The statutes even provide the public with an acceptable form of notice. Compliance with the statute is only a matter of procedure for your company.

If you are in the business of working on projects where notice is required, its as
simple as dropping a form letter into the mail to preserve your lien rights. Even if you’re not typically required to provide notice, nevertheless you might want to consider sending it as it won’t harm any of your lien rights to over-notify the owner.

Posted in:     Uncategorized  /  Tags: , ,   /   3 Comments

Is Notice Required Before Filing a Construction Lien? Louisiana Law

It’s difficult to stress how beneficial filing a lien can be for your company when attempting to collect on a non-paying project. However, this begs the very important, and sometimes difficult to answer question: Are you legally entitled to lien?

In Louisiana, the lien statutes are drafted with a certain balance. On the one hand, the statutes were created to grant those involved with the construction of a project a privilege on the properties they build or improve. On the other hand, however, the statutes have mechanisms within to protect the property owners from being liened improperly, or otherwise without notice.

Unfortunately, the notice requirements are oftentimes confusing and technical. It is important, however, that your organization understand the notice requirements of the Private Works Act.

If you lien a project without following these notice procedures, you will have filed an improper lien. Filing an improper lien subjects you to owing the property owner damages and attorneys fees.

Contracting with the Owner / Resident
Notice is required whenever you are working on a residential project, and you contract directly with the owner of the property, who also lives in the residence.

The type of notice required is called the “Notice of Lien Rights.” A copy of an example of this notice is available by clicking here.

This notice, again, is required when the following elements are present:

1) Work is being done on a residence;
2) You contracted directly with the owner of the residence. In other words, you are not subcontractor on the project;
3) The owner lives in the residence.

The Notice of Lien Rights to be sent to owners in residential projects is very important, because the law requires that it be provided before work begins, and not as a condition to your construction contract.

Lessor of Equipment or Other Movables

If you are leasing equipment or other movable items to any party in a construction project, you are required to deliver a copy of the lease agreement to those who are not parties to that agreement within 10 days of the equipment’s delivery.

For example, if you lease equipment to a subcontractor, you are not required to deliver an additional copy of the lease to the subcontractor within 10 days of delivery because they will – presumably – already have a copy of the lease. However, you would be required to send a copy of the lease to the general contractor and the owner.

This puts those other parties on notice that you have leased equipment/movables to someone for the work at the jobsite, and if such notice is sent, you will have preserved your right to file a lien in the case of non-payment.

Seller of Movables / Materials / Equipment / Etc.

Whenever you sell supplies, or any type of movable property, you are entitled to file a lien on the property where those supplies are incorporated (if they are used in construction of the improvement).

If the materials sold are incorporated into a commercial project, there are no notice requirements.

If the materials sold are incorporated into a residential project, and you would be liening a residence, LA RS 9:4802(G)(2)-(3) requires that you deliver a notice of nonpayment to the owner of the property at least ten (10) days before filing the lien. The notice must:

  • Be served by certified mail, return receipt requested;
  • Contain the name and address of the seller of movables (you);
  • Contain the general description of materials / movables provided;
  • Contain a description sufficient to identify the immovable property against which the lien may be placed;
  • Contain a written statement of the seller’s rights (your rights) for the total amount owed, plus interest and recording fees

If you sold the materials/movables to a subcontractor on the project, the notice must be sent certified, return receipt mail to both the owner and the general contractor.

Conclusion
This blog post discusses the most important and prominent notice requirements within the Louisiana Private Works Act. If you are looking to lien a non-paying construction project, you should familiarize yourself with the Private Works Act and consult with an attorney to ensure that you meeting all the requirements to filing.

Links:

Posted in:     Uncategorized  /  Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,   /   Leave a comment